When tackling yard work, having the right tools makes all the difference. Two popular options for clearing leaves and debris are the Milwaukee 3017-20 and the MZK 1712. Each offers a different approach to the task.
Quick Check
| Fact Name | Milwaukee 3017-20 | MZK 1712 |
|---|---|---|
| Product | ||
| Check Price | Check discount Price on Amazon | Check discount Price on Amazon |
| Wattage | Battery Powered | ac |
| Color | Black/Red | Red |
| Product Dimensions | Not specified | 17″L x 8″W x 15″H |
| Item Weight | 6.9 Pounds | Not specified |
Milwaukee 3017-20 Review
Milwaukee 3017-20: At a Glance
Wattage: Battery Powered
Item Weight: 6.9 Pounds
Voltage: 18 Volts
Special Features: Adjustable Speed, Interchangeable Nozzle Connection
Milwaukee 3017-20
The Milwaukee 3017-20 is a battery-powered tool designed for general yard cleanup. Its adjustable speed allows for control over the airflow, and it features an interchangeable nozzle connection for versatility.
What We Like
- Battery powered for cord-free operation.
- Adjustable speed for tailored airflow.
- Interchangeable nozzle connection offers flexibility.
Things to Consider
- Tool only; battery and charger sold separately.
- Item weight is 6.9 pounds, which may affect extended use comfort.
Milwaukee Electric – M18 FUELTRADE Blower
MZK 1712 Review
MZK 1712: At a Glance
Product Dimensions: 17″L x 8″W x 15″H
Wattage: ac
Special Features: Leaf Vacuum
MZK 1712
The MZK 1712 is a corded electric tool that functions as a leaf blower, vacuum, and mulcher. It boasts powerful airflow and a high mulch ratio for efficient debris reduction.
What We Like
- 3-in-1 functionality: blower, vacuum, and mulcher.
- Powerful airflow with speeds up to 167 MPH.
- 15:1 mulch ratio significantly reduces yard waste volume.
- Large 40L collection bag minimizes emptying.
- Ergonomic handle for comfortable grip.
Things to Consider
- Requires a power outlet and cord management.
- Corded operation limits range and requires an extension cord.
MZK 3 in 1 Electric Leaf Blower Corded, Leaf Vacuum and Leaf Mulcher, 460 CFM, 167 MPH Airflow, Corded Blowers with 40L Leaf Collection Bag for Yard, Garden
The Biggest Difference
The most significant difference lies in their power source and core functionality. The Milwaukee 3017-20 operates on an 18-volt battery system, offering the freedom of cordless movement around your yard. It is primarily a blower, with potential for other tasks via its nozzle connection.
Conversely, the MZK 1712 is a corded electric unit that excels with its 3-in-1 capability, seamlessly switching between blowing, vacuuming, and mulching. This versatility means it can not only clear leaves but also collect and reduce their volume.
What Changes in Real Life
- For larger yards or areas without convenient power access, the freedom of the Milwaukee 3017-20‘s battery power is a major advantage.
- When dealing with large piles of leaves that need to be cleared and disposed of efficiently, the MZK 1712‘s mulching capability saves significant time and effort.
- Users who prefer to avoid the hassle of managing extension cords will find the cordless Milwaukee 3017-20 more convenient.
- For quick, targeted blowing tasks where maneuverability is key, the Milwaukee 3017-20 is effective.
- Tasks involving collecting and reducing debris volume, like clearing garden beds, are handled more efficiently by the MZK 1712‘s vacuum and mulching functions.
- The MZK 1712‘s ability to convert leaves into mulch means fewer trips to the compost bin or trash disposal.
How These Actually Work (And Why It Matters)
The Milwaukee 3017-20 uses an electric motor powered by an M18 battery to spin an impeller, generating airflow directed through a nozzle. This high-speed air stream dislodges and moves leaves and debris, making it effective for clearing surfaces.
The MZK 1712, being corded electric, operates on a similar principle for blowing. However, its design also allows for air to be drawn inward, creating a vacuum. This suction pulls leaves into the unit, where a mulching mechanism breaks them down before they are collected in the bag, drastically reducing their volume.
Which One Is Best for You?
If your primary need is the convenience of a cordless tool for general blowing tasks and you don’t need vacuuming or mulching, the Milwaukee 3017-20 is a solid option. Its battery power offers mobility across your property.
On the other hand, if you frequently deal with large volumes of leaves, require the ability to vacuum and mulch them, and have access to power outlets, the MZK 1712’s 3-in-1 functionality provides greater efficiency for cleanup and debris management.
Which One Fits Your Life?
- If you value cordless freedom and primarily need to blow leaves, the Milwaukee 3017-20 fits your life.
- If you need a tool that can both blow and collect/mulch leaves, the MZK 1712 fits your life.
- If your yard is large and has many power outlets conveniently located, the MZK 1712 fits your life.
- If you want to minimize yard waste volume and the number of trips to dispose of it, the MZK 1712 fits your life.
- If you already own M18 batteries and chargers, the Milwaukee 3017-20 fits your life.
My Honest Recommendation
For users prioritizing the freedom of movement and a tool focused on blowing, the Milwaukee 3017-20 offers a powerful, battery-operated solution. Its adjustable speed and interchangeable nozzle add to its utility for various blowing tasks around the property.
Conversely, if comprehensive debris management, including vacuuming and mulching, is a key requirement, the MZK 1712 stands out with its 3-in-1 functionality. Its high airflow and efficient mulching ratio make it ideal for tackling large amounts of leaf waste.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Milwaukee 3017-20 | MZK 1712 |
|---|---|---|
| Power Source | Battery Powered (18 Volts) | Corded Electric (AC) |
| Primary Function | Blower | Blower, Vacuum, Mulcher |
| Item Weight | 6.9 Pounds | Weight not specified, but corded typically implies lighter handheld operation |
| Special Features | Adjustable Speed, Interchangeable Nozzle Connection | 3-in-1 Functionality, Leaf Vacuum, Mulch Ratio (15:1) |
| Airflow/Speed | Adjustable (specific CFM/MPH not provided) | Up to 460 CFM, up to 167 MPH |
| Collection Bag Capacity | Not applicable (blower only) | 40L |
Specifications Comparison
| Fact Name | Milwaukee 3017-20 | MZK 1712 |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Milwaukee | MZK |
| Model | 3017-20 | 1712 |
| Color | Black/Red | Red |
| Product Dimensions | Not specified | 17″L x 8″W x 15″H |
| Wattage | Battery Powered | ac |
| Item Weight | 6.9 Pounds | Not specified |
| Voltage | 18 Volts | Not specified |
| Special Features | Adjustable Speed, Interchangeable Nozzle Connection | Leaf Vacuum |
Maintenance and Care
For the Milwaukee 3017-20, maintenance primarily involves ensuring the battery is charged and stored properly, and keeping the air intake and nozzle clear of debris. Regular cleaning of the exterior will keep it in good working order.
The MZK 1712 requires regular clearing of the collection bag and ensuring the vacuum and blower tubes are free from obstructions. Inspecting the power cord for damage and keeping the motor housing clean are also important for its longevity.
When to Buy for Better Deals
Finding the right deal can make your yard work more budget-friendly. Both tools offer value depending on your needs.
- Look for bundle deals that might include batteries and chargers for the Milwaukee 3017-20 if you don’t already own them.
- Seasonal sales often feature discounts on outdoor power equipment.
- Check for refurbished options for potential savings on either model.
- Compare prices across different retailers, especially during holiday shopping periods.
FAQs
What is the main advantage of the Milwaukee 3017-20?
The main advantage is its cordless operation, offering greater freedom and maneuverability around the yard.
Can the MZK 1712 be used without a cord?
No, the MZK 1712 is a corded electric tool and requires a power outlet and extension cord to operate.
Does the Milwaukee 3017-20 come with a battery?
No, the Milwaukee 3017-20 is sold as a tool only; the battery and charger must be purchased separately.
How much does the MZK 1712 reduce leaf volume?
The MZK 1712 features a 15:1 mulch ratio, meaning it reduces 15 bags of leaves into 1 bag.
Is the Milwaukee 3017-20 suitable for heavy-duty yard work?
As a tool-only unit, its suitability depends on the battery power used and the specific nozzle attachment for the task.
Quick Links
Final Decision
Both the Milwaukee 3017-20 and the MZK 1712 are capable tools for yard maintenance, each with distinct strengths.
Your choice will depend on whether you prioritize cordless convenience or multi-functional debris management.
In summary, the Milwaukee 3017-20 offers flexibility and cordless convenience for blowing tasks, while the MZK 1712 provides comprehensive debris management with its 3-in-1 blower, vacuum, and mulcher capabilities.
Consider your specific yard cleanup needs, power accessibility, and desired efficiency when making your selection between these two models.
Leave a Reply